GummySearch Alternatives: What to Use Now That It's Shutting Down
Last verified September 21, 2026 · Threadly
The short version. GummySearch closed to new customers on November 30, 2025. Its founder says it could not reach a commercial license with Reddit's data API. Paying customers keep access until their current billing period ends, lifetime-deal holders until November 30, 2026, and the service shuts down entirely with all user data deleted in December 2026 (its own timeline says December 1). Export your account data now.
GummySearch did several jobs
Which replacement is right depends on the one you used most.
| If you used it for | Look at |
|---|---|
| Finding people who want to buy right now | Threadly, or Redreach |
| Free keyword alerts | F5Bot |
| Precise, fast alerts across several communities | Syften |
| Audience research and pain-point discovery | A tool built for research. Threadly is not one. |
See the full comparison of Reddit lead generation tools.
Where Threadly fits
Threadly does one job. It scans Reddit once a day for posts from people looking for what you sell, has Claude judge whether each is a genuine lead and how strong the buying intent is, and drafts a reply that waits in your Approval Inbox. Nothing is ever posted without you. It does not do audience research or subreddit analysis, and if that is what you relied on GummySearch for, it will not replace it.
How to move over
- Export your account data from GummySearch while you still can.
- Pick your ten most important pain-point phrases from that export.
- Give Threadly your website, and it will suggest the phrases people use. Compare them with your ten.
- After the first week, compare the leads Threadly surfaced with what GummySearch was finding for you, and decide whether you need a second tool for research.
Threadly costs $29 a month at its standard price (lower founding prices apply while spots last), with a 7-day free trial and no card required.
Frequently asked questions
Can I still use GummySearch?
Only if you were already a paying customer. GummySearch closed to new signups, renewals and purchases on November 30, 2025. Existing paid customers keep access until their current billing period ends, lifetime-deal holders have access through November 30, 2026, and free users can log in only to export or delete their data. The service shuts down entirely and user data is deleted in December 2026.
Is Threadly a like-for-like replacement for GummySearch?
No. GummySearch covered audience research, subreddit analysis and lead detection. Threadly does one of those jobs: it scans Reddit daily for people looking for what you sell, judges buying intent and drafts a reply for you to approve. It does not do audience research or subreddit analysis.
What replaces GummySearch's audience research?
Threadly does not. If research and pain-point discovery were the main reason you used GummySearch, look for a tool built for research rather than lead finding.
How do I export my data from GummySearch?
Log in while your access is still active and download an export of your account data, which GummySearch says both paid and free users can do. Do this well before December 2026, since all user data is deleted when the service shuts down.
Compare more tools
- Best Reddit lead generation tools, compared
- F5Bot alternative
- Syften alternative
- Redreach alternative
- How to find leads on Reddit: a step-by-step guide
Start a 7-day free trial — no card required.